I have to be thankful that they asked me to take it down before pursuing legal action. So for these reasons, I have no other choice but to take down Card Conjurer. I’m just disappointed that Card Conjurer can no longer do what so many other fan sites have done for years, and continue to do. I understand that Wizards has the right to protect its intellectual property and that the fan content policy includes a clause for arbitrary takedowns. Unfortunately, now that I’m on WoTC’s radar, Card Conjurer can’t get away with it as everyone else does. No one is allowed to use these trademarks without licensing, but as we all know, there are plenty of sites, products, and other content that use these symbols all the time. These primarily include the mana symbols, among other things. Notice that this does not mention copyrights, just trademarks and logos. Ultimately, their attorney listed some examples to warrant taking down Card Conjurer.ġ) verbatim copying of Card text and card art (I can remove card imports)Ģ) messing with their legal notice by placing under their copyright (ok? I can remove that)ģ) Card Conjurer “reproduces, displays and allows the copying and distribution of many of the MAGIC: THE GATHERING trademarks and logos” I was told that Wizards “enforces its rights… as it deems appropriate.” I also asked why Card Conjurer is being C&D’d but not other custom card creators that don’t provide Wizards’ copyright notice, put card frames behind paywalls, have been around longer, and have more users.

I responded by explaining my situation and how I believed that Card Conjurer respected the fan content policy.

I initially received an email from Reynolds Law requesting that I take down my website because it uses copyrighted and trademarked material from Wizards of the Coast. The fact is, Wizards wants it down, and so I must comply. Today, November 18th, I’m taking it down. On November 3rd, 2022, I received a cease and desist for Card Conjurer.

Mtg cardsmith token making